Introduction: The Evolving Role of ILPs in Singapore
Investment-linked policies (ILPs) have long divided opinion among financial experts and investors alike. Once regarded as expensive and opaque, ILPs have since evolved into more transparent and flexible financial tools that combine investment growth with insurance protection.
Despite its reputation, ILPs have adapted to modern market needs — offering investors customizable features, improved transparency, and better cost efficiency. This article explores the evolution of ILPs, their structure, benefits, risks, and the role they can play in today’s diversified financial portfolios.
The Controversy and Misunderstanding Around ILPs
ILPs were once the most misunderstood financial products in Singapore, often associated with poor transparency and investment losses. But many of these issues stemmed from misunderstanding rather than the product itself.
In the 2000s and early 2010s, ILPs became one of the most complained-about products at the Financial Industry Disputes Resolution Centre (FIDReC). New insurance agents often marketed them as all-in-one solutions for education funding, protection, and investment.
Unfortunately, many policyholders bought into these plans without fully understanding the fees, fund risks, or long-term implications. When returns fell short, clients faced unpleasant surprises upon surrendering their policies — and in many cases, their agents were no longer around to provide guidance.
How ILPs Work: The Mechanics Behind the Product
ILPs combine investment and insurance protection, allowing policyholders to access selected funds while paying for coverage and administration costs. The balance between cost and return determines long-term success.
An investment-linked policy (ILP) functions similarly to a structured investment plan. Policyholders allocate premiums into managed funds while paying for optional protection such as life or critical illness coverage.
Costs — including mortality charges and administrative fees — are deducted regularly from investment units, especially during the lock-in period. In return, insurers may provide welcome bonuses and loyalty rewards for policyholders who stay invested. When managed strategically, ILPs can offer competitive results; however, without proper understanding, these same features can erode returns over time.
The Real Cost of Insurance in ILPs
The insurance (mortality) cost in ILPs grows exponentially with age, often reducing net returns in the later years of a policy. Managing this component is key to long-term success.
While the investment funds in an ILP may perform well, the mortality charge — the cost of insurance coverage — increases significantly with age, particularly after 50. Over time, this can offset much of the investment growth.
Older ILPs compounded this issue by allocating only part of premiums to investments during the first few years. As a result, many investors found their policy values stagnating or declining even in rising markets — a key reason for the product’s poor reputation a decade ago.
Why ILPs Remain Popular in Singapore
Despite criticism, ILPs continue to attract investors due to their affordability, flexibility, and perceived upside compared to traditional life insurance.
Many Singaporean families include ILPs in their financial portfolios because these policies offer affordable premiums with potential investment growth.
Agents often promote ILPs as offering “unlimited upside” versus the modest returns of whole life policies. The mix of protection, investment, and flexibility appeals particularly to younger investors seeking a single solution for multiple goals — from education savings to retirement planning.
The Modern ILP: Reinvented and More Transparent
New-generation ILPs have undergone major improvements — 100% premium allocation, better bonuses, and transparent fee structures make them more investor-friendly than before.
Driven by feedback from regulators and consumer feedback, insurers have redesigned ILPs to be fairer and more transparent.
- Full premium allocation: Most plans now invest 100% of premiums from day one.
- Welcome and loyalty bonuses: Clients receive unit bonuses for staying invested long term.
- Customizable coverage: Investors can reduce or remove unnecessary insurance, minimizing cost drag.
- Cost pegging options: Some ILPs tie insurance costs to premium rather than account value, keeping fees predictable.
When timed strategically — for instance, during market downturns — ILPs can also help investors accumulate more fund units at discounted prices.
Fund Selection and Performance: The Deciding Factor
The quality of the underlying funds and active management by advisers determine the ILP’s long-term outcome. Poor fund selection or neglect can quickly erode value.
The underlying fund performance is the single most important determinant of ILP success. While many active funds struggle to outperform benchmarks such as the S&P 500, some managers consistently deliver value above market averages.
Modern ILPs now include:
- Index-linked ETFs for lower costs and passive growth
- High-grade bond funds for stable income
- Sectoral and global equity funds for diversification
However, active oversight remains crucial. Fund managers change, markets shift, and investment goals evolve. Without an adviser’s ongoing monitoring and rebalancing, even the best ILPs can underperform.
ILPs as Part of a Broader Financial Strategy
When integrated thoughtfully, ILPs can complement a diversified portfolio — serving purposes like legacy planning, risk management, and estate protection.
ILPs are often misunderstood as mere investment products. In reality, they are multi-functional financial solutions capable of addressing specific needs such as:
- Legacy and estate planning: ILPs and Index Universal Life (IUL) policies can facilitate wealth transfer, with insurance coverage providing capital certainty.
- Risk diversification: ILPs can complement other investments by adding a protective layer against market downturns.
- Capital protection: Insurance wrapping can buffer against severe market losses while maintaining exposure to potential growth.
When aligned with a client’s goals and risk profile, ILPs can enhance rather than hinder overall financial outcomes.
Balancing ILPs and Platforms for Cost-Efficient Portfolio Growth
ILPs can complement ETFs, unit trusts, or robo-advisors by front-loading most fees during the lock-in period, unlike platforms with ongoing charges. This makes ILPs cost-efficient for long-term investing, while platforms offer tactical flexibility. Together, they provide structure, liquidity, and diversification in a balanced portfolio.
As part of a holistic financial strategy, ILPs can complement investments made through other channels such as ETFs, unit trusts, or robo-advisors. One key difference lies in the fee structure.
- Investment platforms typically charge ongoing wrap and platform fees before GST (usually between 1.0% to 1.5% annually) for as long as the investor holds the position. These recurring costs, combined with fund-level management fees, can gradually erode returns over the years.
- ILPs, on the other hand, front-load most of their costs during the lock-in period. After this period, ongoing charges reduce significantly, and loyalty bonuses or reduced policy fees enhance compounding returns.
For long-term investors, this structure can become advantageous. Once past the early cost intensive phase, ILPs may become more cost-effective compared to platforms due to the absence of reduced product fees.
Strategically, ILPs can serve as core holdings for disciplined, goal-based investing, while platforms can be used for tactical or short-term allocations. By combining both, investors diversify not only across asset classes but also across fee structures, achieving a more efficient overall portfolio.
Rather than viewing ILPs as competitors to investment platforms, investors should see them as complementary instruments — one providing structure and discipline, the other offering flexibility and liquidity. In a balanced portfolio, both can coexist to enhance long-term wealth creation, stability, and diversification.
Conclusion
The True Value Lies in Sound Advice: An ILP’s success depends on proper guidance and sound strategy — not on the product alone. The right adviser can turn ILPs into valuable tools for wealth growth and protection.
Investment-linked policies are not inherently good or bad; they are tools that depend on how they’re used. Just as a doctor prescribes specific medicine for each condition, financial advisers must tailor ILPs to suit each client’s needs and risk appetite.
A knowledgeable adviser who monitors fund performance, manages costs, and aligns strategies with client goals can unlock the true potential of ILPs. Ultimately, the value of any ILP lies in expertise, transparency, and disciplined management — the hallmarks of sound financial planning.
Disclaimer
The information provided in this article is solely for educational purposes and should not be considered as financial advice. The views, statements and opinions expressed in this article are solely the views, statements and opinions of the presenter made in his/her personal capacity and do not represent the views, statements or opinions of nor are they made on behalf of Infinity FA.
The information contained in this presentation has been obtained from public sources which Infinity FA has no reason to believe are unreliable and any analysis, forecasts, projections, expectations and opinions (collectively the “Research”) contained in this presentation are based on such information and are expressions of belief only. Infinity FA has not verified this information and no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made that such information or Research is accurate, complete or verified or should be relied upon as such. Any such information or Research contained in this presentation is subject to change, and Infinity FA shall not have any responsibility to maintain the information or Research made available or to supply any corrections, updates or releases in connection therewith. In no event will Infinity FA be liable for any special, indirect, incidental or consequential damages which may be incurred from the use of the information or Research made available, even if it has been advised of the possibility of such damages.
This presentation is intended for general circulation only and does not take into account the specific investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any particular person.
You should seek advice from a financial adviser regarding the suitability of the investment products mentioned, taking into account your specific investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs, before making a commitment to invest in such products.
Infinity Financial Advisory has policies and procedures in place to eliminate, avoid and manage any potential conflicts of interests that may arise in connection with the production of research reports or analysis. The information presented in this seminar may include references to financial products, securities, or investments. It is important to note that the members of Infinity FA may hold financial interests in the above-mentioned investments products and/or have business relationships with any of the subjected companies covered.
Infinity FA does not endorse any third party’s presentation during the seminar. Infinity FA is not responsible for any action you take in response to such third party’s presentation. Infinity FA accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct, indirect or consequential loss arising from any use of or reliance on the third party’s presentation.
This advertisement has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore.
